The World According to Nick |
My take on Software, Technology, Politics, and anything else I feel like talking about. |
Friday, March 18, 2005
I'll Solve My Own Problems ThanksThe Volokh Conspiracy doesn't like a lot of articles on Slate, and makes no bones about it. Now they point to a critique of Ari Fleischer's memoir and are bashing it pretty well. Eugene mostly bashes the critique for taking quotes out of context, and not revealing that portions of quotes are actually not Ari's quotes, but quotes from other sources he included in the memoir. I on the other hand want to hit one particular point hard:
Hate to break it to you Mr. Noah, but it's not obvious that the government exists to solve problems. I can solve my own problems thanks, and would rather the government keep its nose out of my business. The government exists to protect our country from invasion, and to enforce basic rules (we call them laws) that we as a society have decided to live by. People solve problems, not governments. The very fact that we can't agree how to solve many problems is the very reason why government shouldn't be doing it at all. It's something we call competition. People who think that solution A is the best way to solve the problem would donate money to the Foundation for Solution A. People who think that solution B is better, would likely donate to the Foundation for Solution B. People who wanted A-Type help would go to that foundation, and likewise for B. If A ended up not working for anyone, it would quietly fade away into nothingness while B would continue to grow. What happens now? Solution A ends up sucking... but the government just keeps tossing money at that solution because it's the one "we" decided on. At the same time, B would never have come into existence because once the government creates a solution, it practically makes it impossible for any other to come into being. There was a time when people never went to the government for help. They went to their neighbors, their family, their churches... they got support from people... from their communities. There is nothing wrong with that. It's directed and personal support, and it's a hell of a lot more efficient and helpful than some nameless check that might come in the mail. People who get directed support are much more likely to actually solve their problem and not need support any more. People who only get government help might get their symptoms treated, but tend to get addicted to that help, and never get off it. Now then, I'm not saying that certain solutions aren't best implemented by a government, but that should be a last resort, not a first. It should only be done this way when no private group could do it. Of course, the more you examine the bureaucracy and corruption in government, the more you should see that there are very few tasks which the government is better at doing. Reagan put it best when he said:
|
About Me
Name: Nick Home: Wauwatosa, WI, United States I'm a Software Consultant in the Milwaukee area. Among various geeky pursuits, I'm also an amateur triathlete, and enjoy rock climbing. I also like to think I'm a political pundit. View My Profile Archives
Home PagePrevious Posts
Can You Hear Me Now?Happy St. Patrick's Day It's Supposed to Blow Up You Know You're a Geek When He's Not Far Off the Mark Book Stack Programming Alert: Avert Your Eyes Anti-Blogrolling Well If That's Your Criteria... What is a Libertarian Anyway? Personal Links
Carnival of the Badger
The Coding Monkey del.icio.us Links Flickr Photos Blog Critics Reviews Blogroll Me! music books video culture politics sports gaming www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from Nick_Schweitzer. Make your own badge here.
Credits
Design By maystar |